Compare the highest-rated roofing professionals in Shelter Island, New York. All contractors are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
A premier full-service roofing contractor specializing in high-end residential and commercial properties on Shelter Island. Known for exceptional craftsmanship and expertise in handling insurance claims for storm damage. They use premium materials specifically suited for coastal environments.
Serving the East End including Shelter Island for over two decades, this contractor excels in both asphalt shingle and standing seam metal roof installations. They are particularly adept at designing roofs to withstand nor'easters and salt air corrosion, offering robust warranties on both materials and labor.
A highly-rated local provider known for responsive service and thorough roof inspections. They focus on residential roof repair, replacement, and preventative maintenance, helping homeowners protect their investments from the harsh marine climate. They are a certified installer for several major roofing manufacturers.
The Shelter Island roofing market is specialized due to its unique coastal environment. Contractors must be well-versed in building codes designed for high wind zones and the corrosive effects of salt air. The prevalence of nor'easters and occasional hurricanes makes storm damage restoration and robust, wind-resistant roofing systems (like metal standing seam) particularly important services. The market consists of a mix of local island-based contractors and established companies from the North and South Forks that serve the area.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All contractors are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Shelter Island regulations and climate
Get answers to common questions about roofing services in Shelter Island, New York.
Shelter Island's proximity to the Atlantic Ocean and Long Island Sound means your roof faces salt spray, high humidity, and strong nor'easters. We strongly recommend materials with high corrosion resistance, like aluminum or stainless-steel fasteners, and durable asphalt shingles rated for high winds. Annual inspections, especially after winter and hurricane season, are crucial to check for salt damage, loose shingles, and compromised seals.
For a standard single-family home, a full replacement typically ranges from $15,000 to $40,000+. Key cost factors include the island's higher labor and material transport costs (via ferry), the complexity of your roof's design (common in island architecture), the chosen material (e.g., premium asphalt, metal, or cedar), and the need to comply with local building codes which may require enhanced wind resistance.
Yes, most roofing work requires a building permit from the Town of Shelter Island Building Department. The town adheres to the New York State Uniform Fire Prevention and Building Code, which includes specific wind load requirements for our coastal region (Zone 3). Your licensed contractor should handle this process, ensuring all materials and installation methods meet these codes for your safety and compliance.
The ideal windows are late spring (May-June) and early fall (September-October), avoiding peak summer traffic/ferry delays and the winter freeze-thaw cycles. Weather is the biggest variable, but a standard asphalt shingle replacement for an average home typically takes 2-4 days. Planning well in advance is key due to high demand for reputable local contractors during these optimal seasons.
Prioritize contractors who are familiar with the logistical challenges and building codes of Shelter Island. They must be properly licensed and insured in New York State. Ask for local references you can verify, proof of Workers' Compensation, and detailed written estimates. A trustworthy contractor will proactively discuss ferry scheduling for crews and materials, waste disposal plans, and protection for your property's landscaping.