Compare the highest-rated kitchen remodeling professionals in Shelter Island, New York. All contractors are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
Wave Kitchen & Bath is a highly regarded, full-service design-build firm specializing in luxury kitchen and bath renovations. They are known for their seamless project management, from initial concept and custom design to final installation, making them ideal for complex, high-end Shelter Island projects.
With a strong presence on the South Fork, this company has extensive experience working on Shelter Island homes. They offer a comprehensive range of services, focusing on integrating modern appliances and finishes with the classic aesthetic common to the area. Their strength lies in technical execution and electrical/plumbing updates.
This is a local Shelter Island-based general contractor with a long history on the island. They are the go-to for homeowners seeking a trusted local team for full-home and kitchen renovations. They manage all trades and are deeply familiar with local building codes, regulations, and the specific needs of island properties.
** The kitchen remodeling market in Shelter Island is characterized by its **high-end, bespoke nature** and is heavily influenced by its status as a luxury seasonal destination. The level of competition is moderate; while there are fewer dedicated kitchen-specific showrooms on the island itself, the competition among contractors serving the area from the North and South Forks is strong. Quality is generally very high, catering to a discerning clientele that values custom craftsmanship, durable luxury materials, and timeless design. Typical pricing reflects this premium market. Homeowners should expect: * **Mid-range Full Remodel:** $50,000 - $100,000 * **High-end Custom Remodel:** $100,000 - $250,000+ * **Luxury/Signature Home Remodel:** $250,000+ Projects often involve navigating the logistical complexities of transporting materials and crews via ferry, which is a factor all reputable contractors in this market are accustomed to managing. The most successful providers are those with proven project management skills and the ability to deliver a superior, stress-free client experience.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All contractors are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Shelter Island regulations and climate
Get answers to common questions about kitchen remodeling services in Shelter Island, New York.
Remodeling on Shelter Island typically incurs higher costs and requires more logistical planning due to ferry transportation for all materials, contractors, and crews. You should budget for ferry fees, potential weather-related delays, and a premium for contractors experienced in working on the island, as they factor in travel time and the challenge of coordinating material deliveries around ferry schedules.
Yes, you will likely need a building permit from the Shelter Island Building Department, especially for structural changes, electrical, and plumbing work. Given the island's environmentally sensitive location, there may be additional considerations from the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) for projects affecting drainage or near wetlands. Always consult with your contractor and the Town Building Department first.
The ideal time is during the off-season, from late fall through early spring (October to April). During this period, ferry traffic is lighter, making material and crew transport more reliable, and contractors have greater availability. Summer remodels are challenging due to peak tourist season, ferry congestion, and many homes being occupied, which can lead to longer timelines and higher costs.
Prioritize contractors with verifiable experience working on Shelter Island or the East End, as they understand the unique logistics. Check for proper licensing, insurance, and ask for local references you can actually visit. A reputable local contractor will have established relationships with suppliers and sub-contractors who are accustomed to the ferry system and island-specific challenges.
Absolutely. The marine environment demands materials resistant to moisture and salt air. Opt for cabinetry with durable finishes (like marine-grade paints or stainless steel), countertops such as quartz or solid surface that are non-porous, and hardware with corrosion-resistant finishes. Proper ventilation is also critical to manage humidity and prevent mold growth, which is a common concern in island homes.