Compare the highest-rated bathroom remodeling professionals in Shelter Island Heights, New York. All contractors are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
A highly respected, full-service contracting firm known for meticulous craftsmanship and managing complex projects from design to completion. They specialize in high-end residential renovations and have extensive experience with the unique logistical considerations of working on Shelter Island.
While specializing in tile, this company has evolved into a comprehensive bathroom remodeling expert. They are praised for their creative design input, vast selection of materials, and flawless installation of showers, floors, and wet rooms.
A well-established and highly visible contractor on the East End, specializing in kitchen and bath renovations. They offer a streamlined process with design consultants and in-house project managers, making them a strong choice for comprehensive fixture and layout upgrades.
** The bathroom remodeling market in Shelter Island Heights is characterized by high-quality, custom work tailored to a mix of historic homes and modern luxury estates. Due to the island's affluent and seasonal nature, the competition is among a small pool of elite, established contractors rather than a high volume of companies. Service quality is generally very high, but availability can be a challenge, especially during the peak spring and summer seasons. Homeowners should plan for longer lead times. Typical pricing is at a premium level, reflecting the high cost of materials, the expertise of the contractors, and the logistical expense of transporting crews and materials via ferry. A full, high-end bathroom remodel in this market can realistically range from $45,000 to well over $100,000, depending on the scope, materials, and complexity of the project. Mid-range projects with fixture replacements and tile work typically start in the $25,000 - $40,000 range.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All contractors are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Shelter Island Heights regulations and climate
Get answers to common questions about bathroom remodeling services in Shelter Island Heights, New York.
For a full, mid-range remodel in Shelter Island Heights, homeowners should budget between $25,000 and $45,000. Costs are typically 10-20% higher than mainland averages due to the "island premium" for material delivery and contractor travel. Factors like choosing marine-grade materials for humidity resistance, the complexity of the layout, and the current state of plumbing in older island homes can push costs toward the higher end of this range.
The ferry schedule is a critical path factor; material deliveries and subcontractor arrivals must be meticulously planned around ferry crossings, often adding buffer days to the timeline. Furthermore, most contractors book heavily for the spring and early summer to complete projects before the peak tourist season. To avoid delays, it's highly advisable to schedule your remodel for the late fall or winter and secure a contractor 4-6 months in advance.
Yes, all work must comply with the Town of Shelter Island's building codes and may require permits, especially for plumbing, electrical, and structural changes. Given the area's environmental sensitivity, there are strict regulations regarding wastewater systems (septic/cesspool) that directly impact fixture choices and plumbing layouts. It is essential to hire a contractor familiar with local codes who will pull all necessary permits from the Town Building Department.
Prioritize contractors with proven, verifiable experience working on the Island. They must understand ferry logistics, local suppliers, and the specific permitting process. Check for proper licensing, insurance, and ask for references from past Shelter Island projects you can visit. A reliable local contractor will have established relationships with the ferry lines and supply houses to mitigate logistical challenges.
Shelter Island's high humidity and salty air demand materials that resist moisture. Opt for mold-resistant drywall (green board or cement board), porcelain or ceramic tile, and solid surface or quartz vanities over wood. Ensure your ventilation plan includes a high-CFM, humidity-sensing exhaust fan vented directly outside. Using marine-grade paints and finishes, and avoiding porous natural stones in shower areas, will significantly increase the longevity of your remodel.