Compare the highest-rated bathroom remodeling professionals in Shelter Island, New York. All contractors are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
A highly-rated, full-service remodeling contractor known for personalized service and high-quality craftsmanship in bathroom renovations. They handle projects from initial design and layout to final installation, including custom tile work and fixture upgrades. Their strength lies in clear communication and attention to detail, making them a trusted choice for complex renovations.
A well-established contractor serving the East End, including Shelter Island. They offer comprehensive bathroom remodeling services with a focus on both aesthetic updates and functional layout redesigns. They are experienced in managing projects that require coordination with plumbers and electricians, ensuring a seamless process from start to finish.
Specializing in high-end residential renovations, this company frequently works on Shelter Island properties. They are known for their design-build approach, creating custom, luxury bathrooms that often include accessibility modifications and premium material selections like natural stone and high-end plumbing fixtures.
The bathroom remodeling market in Shelter Island is characterized by high-end, custom projects reflective of the island's affluent, second-home market. Due to the island's small, residential nature, there are very few contractors physically based there. The market is primarily served by established contractors from the North Fork (e.g., Cutchogue, Greenport) and South Fork (e.g., Bridgehampton, Southampton) who are willing to travel and manage the logistics of ferry transport for materials and crew. Competition for high-quality contractors is fierce, especially during the pre-summer season. The level of service quality is generally high, but pricing is at a premium compared to national averages, reflecting the Hamptons-area cost of labor and materials. Typical pricing for a full bathroom remodel in this market can range from $25,000 for a basic update to well over $75,000 for a high-end, custom master bathroom with layout changes and premium finishes. Homeowners should expect longer lead times and plan well in advance.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All contractors are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Shelter Island regulations and climate
Get answers to common questions about bathroom remodeling services in Shelter Island, New York.
For a full remodel on Shelter Island, costs typically range from $25,000 to $60,000+, with high-end projects exceeding $75,000. This reflects the island's higher costs for materials, skilled labor, and transportation/logistics for getting supplies across the ferry. The final price depends heavily on the size of your bathroom, material selections (like tile and fixtures), and the extent of plumbing/electrical work required in your specific home.
Shelter Island's ferry-dependent access and distinct seasonal cycles significantly impact scheduling. Material deliveries must be meticulously coordinated with ferry schedules to avoid costly delays. Furthermore, the humid, maritime climate necessitates selecting mold- and mildew-resistant materials for ventilation and surfaces. Most homeowners plan projects for the spring or fall to avoid peak summer traffic and the potential for winter weather disruptions to the ferry and work crews.
Yes, you will likely need permits from the Town of Shelter Island Building Department. Regulations cover plumbing, electrical, and structural changes, and are crucial given the island's environmental sensitivity and unique septic system requirements (many homes use cesspools or advanced treatment systems). It's essential to work with a contractor familiar with local codes to ensure compliance, especially for projects in flood zones or historic districts.
Prioritize contractors with verifiable experience working on Shelter Island, as they understand the logistical and regulatory challenges. Check for proper licensing, insurance, and local references. Look for a portfolio showing work with styles common to the area, such as coastal, traditional, or modern farmhouse, and ensure they have strong relationships with local suppliers and sub-contractors to streamline the process.
Many island homes are older and may have outdated galvanized steel plumbing, which often requires full replacement with copper or PEX during a remodel. You may also encounter uneven floors, outdated electrical wiring that needs upgrading to current code, and moisture damage in subfloors or walls due to age and humidity. A thorough inspection by your contractor at the start is critical to identify these hidden costs.