Compare the highest-rated bathroom remodeling professionals in Mastic, New York. All contractors are licensed, insured, and verified through our rigorous screening process.
A well-established and highly-rated full-service remodeling company serving Long Island, including Suffolk County. They are known for professional project management, high-quality craftsmanship, and handling all aspects of a renovation from design to completion. They often work on larger-scale projects but also handle standard bathroom remodels.
A national franchise with a strong local presence, Bath Fitter specializes in bathtub and shower liner installations and replacements. Their key strength is speed and minimal disruption, as they fabricate and install custom acrylic wall and tub systems over existing surfaces, often in as little as one day.
A highly-rated local contractor based in nearby Shirley, JV Home Improvements specializes in a wide range of home renovation services with a strong focus on bathrooms and kitchens. They are praised in customer reviews for attention to detail, clear communication, and quality workmanship on both large and small projects.
The bathroom remodeling market in Mastic and the surrounding South Shore of Suffolk County is competitive, with a mix of large, established companies, specialized franchises, and smaller local contractors. The quality of providers ranges significantly, making due diligence on licensing and insurance critically important. Homeowners should be cautious of unlicensed "handymen" for major plumbing and structural work. **Competition Level:** Moderate to High. There are many contractors serving the area, but a smaller subset has the consistent high ratings and specialized focus on full bathroom renovations. **Average Quality:** The top-tier providers offer excellent quality and service, comparable to the wider Long Island market. There is, however, a "long tail" of less reliable operators. **Typical Pricing:** Pricing is in line with the high cost of living on Long Island. A full bathroom remodel can range from **$12,000 - $25,000+**, depending on the size of the bathroom, quality of materials (e.g., standard vs. custom tile, vanity), and the scope of plumbing/structural changes. A tub-to-shower conversion or accessibility modification typically ranges from **$5,000 - $12,000**. It is highly recommended to obtain at least 3 detailed, itemized quotes for any project.
4.7+ star average from verified customer reviews
All contractors are properly licensed and insured
10+ years average experience in the industry
Familiar with Mastic regulations and climate
Get answers to common questions about bathroom remodeling services in Mastic, New York.
For a full, mid-range remodel in Mastic, homeowners can expect to invest between $15,000 and $30,000, with high-end projects exceeding $40,000. This range accounts for Long Island's higher labor and material costs compared to national averages. Key local cost factors include the age of your home (common in Mastic), potential plumbing updates to meet Suffolk County codes, and material choices suited to our coastal humidity.
Mastic's proximity to the Great South Bay means higher humidity and salt air, which can accelerate wear on certain materials. We strongly recommend using mold/mildew-resistant drywall (green board or cement board), ventilation fans that meet current code, and finishes like porcelain tile or solid surface vanities that withstand moisture. Proper sealing of all surfaces is critical to prevent moisture damage common in our area.
Yes, most structural, plumbing, and electrical work in Suffolk County requires a permit from the Town of Brookhaven. This is non-negotiable for ensuring work meets New York State building and energy codes. A reputable local contractor will handle this process, which is crucial for your safety, insurance, and future home resale value in Mastic.
While interior work can be done year-round, late spring through early fall is often ideal. This avoids potential delays from winter weather, which can hinder material deliveries and worker travel. Furthermore, scheduling in these warmer months allows for better ventilation by opening windows during dusty demolition or when paint and sealants are curing.
Always verify a contractor holds a valid Suffolk County Home Improvement Contractor (HIC) license, which is legally required. Check for insurance and ask for references from recent Mastic or South Shore projects. You can also consult the Better Business Bureau and local review sites to see feedback from other Brookhaven Township homeowners.